Studies in Ven. Buddhadatta's Prosody

3: Abhidhammàvatàra

 

1: The Text

Abhidhammàvatàra is a summary In the Ganthàrambhakathà, it describes itself as a hatthasàram, or handbook.01 of the Abhidhamma in 24 Chapters, most of which is written in verse. Chapters 1 - 3, 10 - 13, 19, 23 & 24 contain prose sections also, which is sometimes quite extensive. There are 1416 verses (5664 lines) in the work altogether, mainly written in the Siloka metre (98%), which means that only 29 verses (2%) of the verses are written in other metres. They are used mainly at the close of the various sections, which is the way these metres are normally employed in Classical works, which are not of the Kavyà-type. Neither of the previous works examined, though, are restricted in this way, and the Classical metres occur frequently in the body of the text also.02

 

2: Sarabhatti & Resolution

As with the other studies we can note that sarabhatti and resolution are again abundant in this work. The sarabhatti vowels are mainly of the ÝriyÝ type, as in the other works, There are 4 exceptions, 2 at 112d & 1279c, where there is sarabhatti in antarahite; and 2 at 246a & 247a, reading arahato.03 they are found in the following 29 places: pariÝ 19d, 719b; nàparàpariyavedanaü 46b; pariyesita 80a; vãriyaÝ, which we should read as viriyaÝ 112d, 1279c; Even after counting the sarabhatti vowel this Siloka line is 9 syllables, and therefore hypermetric.04 råpãriyàpatha 143a; ariyadehinaü 278b; arahato 246a, 274a; tiõõamariyànamàdito 281b; apari 345a, 352a, 360a; iriyàpatho 885c; antarahite 1018b, 1093a; pariyodàte 1050b; ÝpariÝ 1126d, 1381c; pariyaü 1159c; ariyamaggo 1188b; pariyattiÝ 1191a; upapajjàparàpari 1243c; pariyo 1316bd; anàgàmiriyasàvako 1364d; ariyàya 1374b; sacchikiri 1378d.

Example:

 

ÜÜÛÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
ßvuññhànagàminãyà hi, pariyosànanû ti bhàsitaü,

ÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
ÿeyyaü sabbapakàrena, pariyosànan-ti gotrabhu. [1316]

 

Resolution occurs 48 times, in the following words: manaÝ 113b, 1060b; ÝcaraÝ 134a, 205c, 344a, 351c, 523a; viciÝ 140c; kusaÝ 161c; javaÝ 165d; sakaÝ 239d, 240a, 336d, 337a; samaÝ 510d, 1383ac; pañiÝ 520a, 602a, 1185a; puriÝ 598b, 904a; upaÝ 629a, 1089c; catuÝ 647c; hadaÝ 742c; niraÝ 744b; paraÝ 778a,d; tatiÝ 778b; ÝbhavaÝ 835c; ubhaÝ

927c; pañhaÝ 932a, 987d, 1311b; ÝsahaÝ 974c, 975a; kasiÝ 1049a; abhiÝ 1051c, 1087a; apaÝ 1244a; anuÝ 1265a; ÝsamuÝ 1270ab; navaÝ 1298c, 1301d; udaÝ 1300a; ÝgataÝ 1309b;

Resolution occurs at the 1st syllable 34 times; 6 times at the 4th; & 8 times at the 5th.

Example:

 

ÛÛÜÛÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
paramatthato ca paÿÿatti, tatiyà koñi na vijjati;

ÜÛÜÜÐÛÛÛÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   navipulà
dvãsu ñhànesu kusalo, paravàdesu na kampati. [778]

 

3: Analysis of the metres

a: Siloka

The idiosyncracies seen in the other studies of Ven. Buddhadatta's usage of the Siloka prevail here also. There are 2709 Siloka pàdayuga-s in total, of which 2576 (95%) are pathyà. As the example we can quote the Ganthàrambhakathà (vss. 1 - 7):

 

ÛÜÛÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
anantakaruõàpaÿÿaü, tathàgatam-anuttaraü,

ÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÛ   pathyà
vanditvà sirasà buddhaü, dhammaü sàdhugaõam-pi ca. [1]

 

ÜÛÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
paõóukam-balanàmàya, silàyàtulavikkamo,

ÛÜÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
nisinno devaràjassa, vimale sãtale tale. [2]

 

ÜÜÛÜÐÜ,ÜÜÜÐÐÜÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   mavipulà
yaü devadevo devànaü, devadevehi påjito,

ÜÜÛÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
desesi devalokasmiü, dhammaü devapurakkhato. [3]

 

ÜÜÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
tatthàhaü pàñavatthàya, bhikkhånaü piñakuttame,

ÛÛÜÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
abhidhammàvatàran-tu, madhuraü mativaóóhanaü. [4]

 

ÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
tàëaü mohakavàñassa, vighàñanam-anuttaraü,

ÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
bhikkhånaü pavisantànaü, abhidhammamahàpuraü. [5]

 

ÛÜÛÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
suduttaraü tarantànaü, abhidhammamahodadhiü,

ÛÜÛÜÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
suduttaraü tarantànaü, taraü va makaràkaraü. [6]

 

ÜÛÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
àbhidhammikabhikkhånaü, hatthasàram-anuttaraü,

ÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
pavakkhàmi samàsena, taü suõàtha samàhità. [7]

 

Of the variations they occur in 5% of the pàdayuga-s, the distribution being as follows:

The normal mavipulà (ÅÅÛÅÐÜ,ÜÜé) lines occur 43 times: 3a; 13a; 278a; 308a; 335c; 339c; 397c; 422c; 445a; 456c; 494a; 520a; 586c; 597a; 602c; 653c; 658a; 706a; 714c; 721a; 787a; 802c; 826c; 835c; 845c; 862c; 908a; 912c; 1013a; 1025a; 1140c; 1154c; 1222a; 1223a; 1259c; 1272c; 1307a; 1308a; 1318a; 1340a; 1345a; 1346a; 1396a.

The mavipulà-type (ÅÅÅÅÐÜÜÜé) lines occur 30 times in all:

17 have the correct break, but an incorrect opening: 134a; 157a, 205c; 344a; 351c; 505c; 523a; 531c; 602c; 722c; 758a; 847a; 1122c; 1203ac; 1313a; & 1397c.

3 have the correct opening, but an incorrect word-break: 10c, 1069a; & 1133c.

10 are abnormal in both ways: 364a; 410a; 724a; 736c; 722a; 839c; 1127a; 1209a; &1383ac.

The distribution of the other variations is as follows:

Besides these there are also 4 Anuññhubha pàdayuga-s (ÅÅÅÅÐÛÜÛé): 428c, 552a, 556a, 716c.

There are also 21 lines which have 9 syllables in them, with no easy way to correct the metre: 197c; 320c; 324a; 528c; 530a; 574c; 575b; 742d; 993b; 1005c; 1061d; 1157b; 1165c; 1180a; 1209c; 1234c; 1263a; 1305a; 1350c; 1358c; & 1384d.

There are light syllables in 2nd and 3rd positions in the following 22 lines: 13c; 27a; 78c; 102a; 278c; 297c; 564b; 582c; 593a; 705b; 712a; 749c; 750a; 756a; 836b; 889a; 1127a; 1205a; 1246a; 1247c; 1271a; & 1408c.

Some examples:

 

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   bhavipulà
yadà catutthaü kusalaü, javanaü hoti tena ca,

ÜÜÛÜÐÜ,ÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   mavipulà
tulyaü catutthaü pàkaü tu, tadàrammaõataü vaje. [397]

 

ÜÛÜÜÐÛÛÛÜÐÐÛÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   navipulà
kucchitànaü salanato, kusànaü lavanena và,

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÜÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   mavipulà-type
kusena làtabbattà và, kusalan-ti pavuccati. [10]

 

ÛÛÜÛÐÜ,ÜÜÜÐÐÛÜÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   mavipulà-type
tadanantaraü taü hoti, tathà saïkhàragocaraü,

ÛÛÜÛÐÛÛÜÜÐÐÛÛÜÜÐÛÜÛÜ   savipulà
tatiyaü javanacittaü, anuloman-ti saÿÿitaü. [1313]

 

ÜÛÜÛÐÛÜÜÜÐÐÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   pathyà
Tattha tikkhaõasampattaü, paccuppannakhaõàdikaü;

ÜÜÜÜÐÛÛÜÛÐÐÜÜÜÛÐÛÜÛÜ   savipulà
ekadvesantativàrapariyàpannam-idaü pana. [1126cd]

 

b: Other Metres

There are only 29 verses which are not in Siloka metre in this work (2% of the total). They are mainly written in Classical metres of one sort or another.

There is a very rare Upagãti verse in this work, which is a Gaõàcchandas metre:

 

ÛÛÛÛÐÛÛÛÛÐÛÛÜÐÐÜÛÛÐÜÜÐÛÐÜÛÛÐÜ
sumadhuravarataravacano, kaü nu janaü neva raÿjayati,

ÛÛÛÛÐÛÛÛÛÐÜÜÐÐÛÜÛÐÛÛÜÐÛÐÜÜÐÜ
atinisitavisadabuddhipasàdajana vedanãyoyaü. [979]

 

There is also a verse at 1169 in an unidentified metre which appears to scan as a gaõacchandas metre of some sort or other, but as it is it doesn't fit into any scheme that I am aware of:

 

ÛÛÜÐÛÜÛÐÛÜÛÐÜÜÐÜ
vividhatthavaõõapadehi sampannaü,

ÛÛÐÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÐÜÜÐÜ
madhuratthamatinãharaü ganthaü;

ÜÛÛÐÜÛÛÐÛÛÜÐÛÛÜ
sotujanassa hadayapãtikaraü,

ÛÜÛÐÜÛÛÐÛÜÛÐÜÛÜ
suõeyya koci manujo sacetano. [1169]

 

Next come the Mattàcchanda-s verses. In this work there is one verse in Vetàlãya metre, though we need to make a number of corrections to the text for it to scan properly: Following Smith (Saddanãti, p. 1156) I correct anunaü to aõuü in line a; then in line c we need to read d›ràsade; & -ñhÏne in line d.05

 

ÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
avagacchati yo imaü aõuü,

ÛÛÜÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
paramaü tassa samantato mati;

ÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
abhidhammanaye d›ràsade,

ÛÛÜÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
atigambhãrañhÏne vijambhate. [88]

 

Next there are 2 metres in Addhasamavutta metres:

Aparavatta = 2 (788 & 1401):

 

ÛÛÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
atimatikaramàdhinãharaü,

ÛÛÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
vimativinàsakaraü piyakkaraü;

ÛÛÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
pañhati suõati yo sadà imaü,

ÛÛÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
vikasati tassa matãdha bhikkhuno. [788]

 

Pupphitaggà = 1

 

ÛÛÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜÜ
sumatimativibodhanaü vicittaü,

ÛÛÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜÜ
kumatimatindhanapàvakaü padhànaü;

ÛÛÛÛÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜÜ
imam-atimadhuraü avedi yo yo,

ÛÛÛÛÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜÜ
jinavacanaü sakalaü avedi so so. [559]

 

The rest are Samavutta metres:

11 syllables:

Upajàti = 5 (126, 376, 767, 1262, This verse has a very irregular break in line c.06 1374).

 

ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
saddhena sammà pana bhàvanãyà,

ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
ariyàya paÿÿàya ca bhàvanàya;

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
visuddhikàmena tapodhanena,

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
bhavakkhayaü patthayatà budhena. [1374]

 

Indavajirà = 2 (474, 1376)

 

ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ   
andhajjanànaü hadayandhakàraü,

ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
viddhaüsanaü dãpam-imaü jalantaü;

ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
sikkhetha dhãro satataü payutto,

ÜÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÜ
mohandhakàràpagamaü yadicche ti. [474]

 

Dodhaka = 4 (181, 375, 1103, 1226)

 

ÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÜ
ekavidhàdinaye panim-asmiü,

ÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÜ
yo kusalo matimà idha bhikkhu;

ÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÜ
tassabhidhammagatà pana atthà,

ÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÜ
hatthagatàmalakà viya honti. [181]

 

Rathoddhatà = 1

 

ÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÛÜ
bhàvanànayam-ahaü hitànayaü,

ÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÛÜ
mànayaÿ-ca sugataü sukhànayaü;

ÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÛÜ
byàkaromi paramaü ito paraü,

ÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÛÜ
taü suõàtha madhuratthavaõõanaü. [789]

 

Vàtummã = 1

 

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ   
dànaü sãlaü bhàvanà pattidànaü,

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
veyyàvaccaü desanà cànumodo;

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
diññhijjuttaü saüsuticcàpacàyo,

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
ÿeyyo evaü puÿÿavatthuppabhedo. [21]

 

Saïgatà See Smith Saddanãti, p. 1167. In line b the 1st syllable is unexpectedly heavy.07 = 1

 

ÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÜÛÜ
yato sumatinà mato nàmato,

ÜÜÛÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜ
àyàcitasammànato mànato;

ÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÜÛÜ
tato hi racito sadà tosadà,

ÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÜÜÛÜ
mayà hitavibhàvanà bhàvanà. [1402]

 

12 syllables:

Vaüsaññhà = 2 (62, 1394)

 

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ   
kriyàkriyàpattivibhàgadesako,

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
kriyàkriyaü cittam-avoca yaü jino;

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÜÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
hitàhitànaü sakriyàkriyàrato,

ÛÜÛÜÐÜÛÛÐÜÛÜÛÜ
kriyàkriyaü tan-tu mayà samãritaü. [62]

 

Toñaka = 2 (29, 87)

 

ÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜ
kusalàkusalehi vipàkakriyà -kr- in -kriyà fails to make position in this line.08

ÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜ
hadayehi yutà pana cetasikà;

ÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜ
sakalàpi ca sàdhu mayà kathità,

ÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÛÜ
sugatena mahàmuninà kathità. [87]

 

Bhujaïgappayàta = 1

 

ÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
imaÿ-càbhidhammàvatàraü susàraü,

ÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
varaü sattamohandhakàrappadãpaü;

ÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
sadà sàdhu cinteti vàceti yo taü,

ÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜÛÜÜ
naraü ràgadosà ciraü nopayanti. [290]

 

13 syllables:

Mattamayåra = 1

 

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÛÜÜÛÛÜÜ
råpàråpajjhànasamàpattividhànaü,

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÛÜÜÛÛÜÜ
jànàtãmaü ChSa: jànàtimaü here, and àpattãsu in line c.09 sàrataraü yo pana bhikkhu;

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÛÜÜÛÛÜÜ
råpàråpajjhànasamàpattisu dakkho,

ÜÜÜÜ,ÜÛÛÜÜÛÛÜÜ
råpàråpaü yàti bhavaü so abhibhuyya. [1042]

 

Unidentified = 1 This metre is listed by Smith on p. 1166 of Saddanãti, but he doesn't have a name for it, and I also have been unable to identify it so far.10

 

ÜÜÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜ
maggàmaggaÿàõadassanesu kovidà,

ÜÜÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜ
sàràsàravedino samàhitàhità;

ÜÜÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜ
maggàmaggaÿàõadassananti taü idaü,

ÜÜÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜÛÜ
buddhà buddhasàvakà vadanti vàdino. [1297]

 

14 syllables:

Vasantatilakà = 1

 

ÜÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÜÜ
chandàdhimokkhamudità manasã ca kàro,

ÜÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÜÜ
majjhattatà ca karuõà viratittayaü ca,

ÜÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÜÜ
puÿÿesu tena niyatàniyatà ca sabbe,

ÜÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÛÛÜÛÜÜ
yevàpanà munivarena na ceva vuttà. [73]

 

19 syllables:

Saddålavikkãëita = 1

 

ÜÜÜÛÛÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÜÜÛÜÜÛÜ
saddhàbuddhikaraü tathàgatamate sammohaviddhaüsanaü,

ÜÜÜÛÛÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÜÜÛÜÜÛÜ
paÿÿàsambhavasampasàdanakaraü jànàti yo ce imaü;

ÜÜÜÛÛÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÜÜÛÜÜÛÜ
atthabyaÿjanasàlinaü sumadhuraü sàraÿÿuvimhàpanaü,

ÜÜÜÛÛÜÛÜÛÛÛÜÜÜÛÜÜÛÜ
gambhãre nipuõàbhidhammapiñake so yàbhiniññhaü padaü. [777]

 

last updated: March 2006